top of page

Trademark Infringement

Trademark infringement is the unauthorized use of a trademark or service mark on or in connection with goods and services in a manner that is likely to cause confusion, deception, or mistake about the source of the goods and services. This unauthorized use of a trademark can damage your brand's reputation, result in financial losses, and halt business operations.

Photo of the outside of a McDonald's at night | Trademark, Copyright, Patent Law | Top Rated Attorney in New York | Manhattan | TCP Law

A successful trademark infringement claim requires a showing of:

Establishing a Trademark Infringement Claim

1.

A valid and enforceable trademark.

If a trademark infringement claim is based on a common law mark rather than a federal trademark registration, it must be shown that the mark is legally protectable and that the scope of protection includes the infringing use.

3.

The use of the mark in connection with goods and services that are the same or similar to those associated with the trademark, such as to cause a likelihood of confusion among consumers.

2.

A mark that is confusingly similar to the trademark.

1.

Strength of the trademark

2.

Similarity of the marks

3.

Proximity of the products and their competitiveness with one another

4.

Evidence that the senior user may “bridge the gap” by developing a product for sale in the market of the alleged infringer’s product

A key element of trademark infringement is a showing of a likelihood of confusion (LOC) between the marks. A LOC occurs when a customer is likely to mistake the source of goods or services offered by different sources using similar marks.

​

The New York federal courts use the Polaroid factors to determine LOC. These factors are intended as a guide, and not all factors may be particularly helpful in any given case.

Likelihood of Confusion

5.

Evidence of actual consumer confusion

6.

Evidence that the imitative mark was adopted in bad faith

7.

Respective quality of the products

8.

Sophistication of consumers in the relevant marke

Trademark Dilution

Trademark dilution occurs when a trademark is used in a way that harms the trademark owner's reputation or diminishes the unique association of the trademark with the owner's goods or services. Trademark dilution does not require trademark infringement.

 

In the United States, there are two types of dilution, namely dilution by blurring and dilution by tarnishment. Blurring occurs when the distinctiveness of a famous mark is impaired due to unauthorized use. Tarnishment occurs when a famous mark's unauthorized use is offensive and harms its reputation.

Suppose the trademark infringement elements can be shown. In that case, the trademark owner may seek remedy in court, including an injunction to prevent further use of the infringing mark, compensation for damages caused by the infringement, and the seizure of any products infringing on the trademark. In some cases, attorney's fees and costs may also be awarded. Treble damages may be available in appropriate situations.

Trademark Infringement Remedies

The USPTO's Trademark Trial and Appeal Board (TTAB) provides a venue to handle certain trademark disputes outside of the courts.

TTAB Proceedings

Appeals

Appeals at the TTAB provide a forum to appeal rejections of a mark by an examining attorney during the prosecution of a trademark application.

Cancellations

Cancellations at the TTAB allow third parties to petition to cancel an existing trademark registration if they believe they have been or will be negatively affected by the registered trademark.

Oppositions

Oppositions at the TTAB provide a forum for third parties who assert that they may be harmed by the registration of a mark that has been allowed by the USPTO and published in the Official Gazette.

Trademark Infringement FAQ

What is trademark infringement?

Trademark infringement is the unauthorized use of a trademark or service mark on or in connection with goods and services in a manner likely to cause confusion, deception, or mistake about their source. It can damage your brand's reputation, result in financial losses, and halt business operations. Learn about the differences between trademark infringement and dilution or contact TCP Law to assess a potential infringement situation.

What must a trademark owner prove to win an infringement claim?

A successful trademark infringement claim requires proving three elements: a valid and enforceable trademark; a mark used by the defendant that is confusingly similar to the plaintiff's mark; and use of that mark in connection with the same or similar goods and services likely to cause consumer confusion. For common law marks, the claimant must also demonstrate the scope of their unregistered rights. Contact TCP Law to evaluate the strength of your claim.

What is likelihood of confusion, and how do New York federal courts evaluate it?

Likelihood of confusion (LOC) is the central standard in trademark infringement — it occurs when consumers are likely to mistake the source of goods or services offered under similar marks. New York federal courts apply the eight Polaroid factors, including the strength of the mark, similarity of the marks, proximity and relatedness of goods and services, evidence of actual confusion, and consumer sophistication. Contact TCP Law to assess your LOC argument.

What is trademark dilution, and how is it different from infringement?

Trademark dilution harms a trademark owner's reputation or diminishes the unique association of a famous mark — without requiring consumer confusion. There are two types: dilution by blurring (unauthorized use impairs a famous mark's distinctiveness) and dilution by tarnishment (offensive unauthorized use harms the mark's reputation). Unlike infringement, dilution applies only to famous marks. Read about trademark infringement vs. dilution or contact TCP Law to evaluate your claim.

What remedies are available if my trademark infringement claim succeeds?

Successful trademark infringement remedies include: an injunction stopping further use of the infringing mark; compensation for damages caused by infringement; seizure of infringing products; attorney's fees in appropriate cases; and treble damages where infringement was willful. Federal registration significantly expands the remedies available. The earlier the enforcement action is taken, the stronger your position. Contact TCP Law to discuss your enforcement options or send a cease and desist letter.

What TTAB proceedings are available for trademark disputes?

The Trademark Trial and Appeal Board (TTAB) handles three types of proceedings: appeals of USPTO examining attorney rejections during trademark prosecution; oppositions filed by third parties against marks published in the Official Gazette; and cancellation petitions against existing registrations. TTAB proceedings involve formal procedural rules and evidence requirements. Read about responding to trademark final rejections or contact TCP Law for TTAB representation.

Can I bring a trademark infringement claim without a federal registration?

Yes — infringement claims can be based on common law trademark rights arising from actual use in commerce, even without USPTO registration. However, common law claims carry a higher evidentiary burden and are geographically limited to areas of active use. Federal registration creates a presumption of nationwide ownership and significantly strengthens enforcement. Learn about common law vs. registered trademark rights and contact TCP Law to evaluate your position.

What should I do if I receive a trademark infringement claim against my business?

Do not ignore it. Review the asserted mark's validity, assess whether your mark is actually confusingly similar under the likelihood of confusion standard, and evaluate available defenses. Options include compliance, negotiated resolution, a legal rebuttal, or challenging mark validity. TCP Law assists clients on both sides of trademark disputes. If you've received a cease and desist letter, contact TCP Law immediately to protect your position.

What role does bad faith play in trademark infringement?

Bad faith — evidence that an infringing mark was adopted with knowledge of the senior user's mark — is one of the eight Polaroid factors New York federal courts apply in trademark infringement cases. While not required to prove infringement, bad faith strengthens the plaintiff's position and can affect available remedies. Courts are less sympathetic to defendants who deliberately mimicked an established mark. Contact TCP Law to discuss the strength of your infringement case.

Is it a myth that trademark infringement only occurs when someone copies my mark exactly?

Yes — exact copying is not required. The legal standard is likelihood of confusion, not identity. A phonetically similar name, visually similar logo, or conceptually parallel slogan used on related goods or services can constitute infringement. New York federal courts evaluate this through the eight Polaroid factors. If a competitor is using a similar mark, contact TCP Law to assess whether it rises to trademark infringement.

Trademark Infringement FAQ

How TCP Law Can Help

Employing the services of a trademark attorney at TCP Law can significantly help you protect and enforce your trademark rights. A trademark attorney will help you assess the strength of a trademark infringement claim, whether you are asserting the claim or responding to a claim asserted against your business.

​

If you have general trademark questions or want to discuss your specific trademark matter, please contact me at john@tcplawfirm.com or at 917-612-1059.

Recommended For You

bottom of page